Last January, 38 homes closed in Collierville. Last June, 118 did. Those two numbers explain most of the advice you'll hear about waiting for spring, and they are accurate. Across last spring as a whole, Collierville averaged a little more than twice as many closings a month as it did in January.
The price numbers don't move nearly as much. Across the past fourteen months, Collierville's median sale price stayed mostly between about $485,000 and $570,000. The only months below that range were January and February 2026, which had the fewest sales of the year. In those months a handful of closings set the median, so it says more about which homes sold than about what the market would pay. Over the past year the deed records show buyer volume rising and falling with the seasons while Collierville prices stayed close to level. Most homeowners deciding on a listing date are weighing those two things against each other. A second question matters as much: what a Collierville resale is actually competing against right now. For most homes, that is no longer new construction.
What Last Winter Looked Like in the Deed Records
The Memphis Area Association of Realtors publishes monthly sales for each city from public deed records in Shelby, Fayette and Tipton counties. These are Collierville's figures from July 2025 through August 2026:
| Month | Collierville sales | Median sale price |
|---|---|---|
| July 2025 | 70 | $521,150 |
| August 2025 | 81 | $514,300 |
| September 2025 | 89 | $485,000 |
| October 2025 | 76 | $499,000 |
| November 2025 | 55 | $495,000 |
| December 2025 | 59 | $495,000 |
| January 2026 | 38 | $397,500 |
| February 2026 | 47 | $454,000 |
| March 2026 | 73 | $555,000 |
| April 2026 | 53 | $543,000 |
| May 2026 | 92 | $505,000 |
| June 2026 | 118 | $510,500 |
| July 2026 | 82 | $570,723 |
| August 2026 | 80 | $509,625 |
From December 2025 through February 2026, Collierville averaged 48 closings a month. From March through June 2026 it averaged 84. That gap is real, and it is the strongest argument for spring.
January's $397,500 median is the figure that worries sellers, but it isn't a winter discount. That month had 38 sales, and only one of them was a new home, compared with 12 new-home sales in January a year earlier. With a sample that small, a few closings at the lower end of the market can pull the median down by six figures. Two months later, with nearly twice as many sales, the March 2026 median was $555,000.
December deserves its own look. Collierville recorded 59 sales in December 2025, more than the 55 in November and well above the 38 in January. Buyers kept closing in Collierville through the holiday month, and the drop came after the new year.
The September Number That Looks Worse Than It Is
MAAR's September 2026 report, released October 14, shows 51 Collierville sales, down 42.0% from 88 in September 2025, while the median rose 2.1% to $495,000. Read alone, that sales drop sounds like the start of a slowdown.
The year-to-date figures from the same report don't support that reading. From January through September 2026, Collierville recorded 634 total sales, compared with 647 over the same months of 2025. Total sales were down 2.0%, while existing-home sales rose 3.2%, from 566 to 584. The year-to-date median for all Collierville sales was $510,000, down 2.4%, and the existing-home median was $490,750, down 2.7%. Resale demand in Collierville has held up this year. Through September, resales were the part of the market that grew.
The wider market has more homes for sale than it did a year ago. MAAR counted 4,910 active listings across the metro in September 2026, compared with 4,571 in September 2025, and average days on market was 62. The Commercial Appeal reported in August that the larger supply was giving suburban buyers more room to negotiate. The same paper reported that first-half 2026 sales in the Shelby County suburbs were 1,560, compared with 1,561 a year earlier. Taken together, these figures show steady demand and more homes for buyers to choose from. Buyers this season will compare more listings before they write an offer, whatever month a seller chooses.
Where Collierville's Builders Have Priced Their Homes
The biggest change in Collierville this year is in new construction. Through September 2026, new-home sales fell 38.3%, from 81 to 50, while the median new-home price rose 21.0% to $739,559. That median is about $250,000 above the year-to-date median for existing homes.
Builder advertising this fall shows the same gap. Magnolia Homes lists Cypress Grove from $765,955 with a newly opened phase, Oak Hill from $829,999, and its last homes in Shepherd's Creek from $1,635,000. Eagle Builders lists Hidden Creek, which has Phase 2 homesites, from the $800,000s. More neighborhoods are in the planning record. Lockwood was described as a 132-lot subdivision at the Collierville planning commission's June 4, 2026 meeting, and Hinton Preserve was approved in 2022 for 84 lots.
For a seller with an established four-bedroom home in the $450,000 to $600,000 range, this means the competition is other resales. The buyer who walks through that house in January is unlikely to have a brand-new home at the same price as the alternative. At the higher end the picture is different. A seller listing at $750,000 or more is competing with model homes, new finishes and builder warranties. A winter listing at that price needs to be prepared, priced and presented against those builder listings, not against older homes nearby. Our earlier look at new construction and established homes in Collierville covers how buyers compare the two.
The One Place a Builder Is After the Same Buyer
The exception is at the lower end of the price range. Eagle Builders' The Towne at Collierville advertises townhomes from $399,000, each with more than 2,000 square feet, a first-floor primary suite and a rear two-car garage. One move-in-ready example is 926 Aldwick Drive, an Ashford plan with 2,108 square feet at $399,000. Eagle is also advertising up to $25,000 at closing on select homes for qualified buyers who sign a contract by November 30, 2026. Buyers can apply it to closing costs, a mortgage rate buydown or the first year of HOA dues, which the builder lists at $4,100 a year covering exterior maintenance, insurance and lawn care.
For a Collierville seller with a smaller, low-maintenance home near $400,000, The Towne is direct competition, and its incentive runs through the end of this month. If you plan to list that kind of home in December or January, check what The Towne is offering when you list, because the buyer touring your home will probably have toured theirs too.
Setting Up a Winter Listing in Collierville
Price against Collierville resales from the past several months. With 38 to 59 closings a month last winter, an appraiser looking for recent comparable sales has fewer to choose from. A list price based on spring sales and well-chosen neighborhood comparables is easier to support at appraisal than one based on a single strong month. Our home valuation page is a starting point, and we can then adjust the figure for your street and your home's condition.
Decide before the holidays. Last December, Collierville recorded 59 closings, the most of any month from November through February. A home that is photographed and ready by the first week of December goes on the market while buyers are still active.
If spring fits your plans better, the reason is the number of buyers. Over the past year, Collierville's spring months had more buyers but not consistently higher prices than the rest of the year. A seller who has to time a purchase, a move or a job change has more to gain from a firm date than from waiting for an assumed spring premium. If you are buying and selling at the same time, our sellers team can plan both sides around the date that works.
Questions Collierville Sellers Ask About Winter
Does a winter listing in Collierville sell for less? The deed records show fewer winter sales, while median prices outside the lowest-volume months stayed in the same general range as the rest of the year. Last winter's lowest median, $397,500 in January 2026, came from just 38 sales, and the median was $555,000 by March 2026.
Is new construction drawing buyers away from Collierville resales? For most resales, the evidence says no. Collierville's year-to-date new-home median through September 2026 was $739,559, and new-home sales were down 38.3% from 2025, while existing-home sales rose 3.2%. Townhomes near $400,000 are the main exception.
The figures in this post, including the builder incentive and HOA dues, are general market information as published on the dates noted, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm your own situation with the right professional.
If you are deciding between a December and a March listing date for your Collierville home, Judy McLellan & The JudyMac Team would be glad to go over last winter's Collierville sales with you and how your home compares with what buyers are seeing this season. Contact Us.